We've received your submission. The Sun beat the odds, however, with Judge Andrew Nicol from the Royal Courts of Justice ruling against Depp. ST. LAWRENCE COUNTY, N.Y. (WWTI) The results are in. Nicol ruled against Depp, accepting that 12 of 14 alleged accounts of violence committed by Depp against Amber Heard were true. This was hardly the first time that Gardner's prosecutors have no-showed. "The circuit attorney's office appears to be a rudderless ship of chaos," said Noble. Related:Divisive Amber Heard Blamed For Aquaman Star Jason Momoas Divorce. The actor sued her after she claimed in a 2018 The Washington Post op-ed piece that she was a victim of domestic abuse. Depp said they were fake. Months later, in May 2021, he retired from London's High Court (Queen's Bench Division) after more than 40 years as a legal. Law enforcement investigate the scene of a shooting at Central Visual and Performing Arts High School Monday, Oct. 24, 2022, in St. Louis. (Christian Gooden/St. April 12 marked the start of the historicJohnny Depp and Amber Heard defamation lawsuit in Fairfax, Virginia. The million dollar question however remains: WHY and HOW?! #JusticeForJohnnyDepp," another added. eventCategory: event.slot.getSlotElementId(), Republican Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey argues that St. Louis Circuit Attorney Kim Gardner 'unlawfully' 'refuses to do her . Market data provided by Factset. Depps claim of new and important evidence was nothing more than a press strategy, and has been soundly rejected by the court, they said in a statement at the time. Judges ruling: Since Depp was never cross-examined about the alleged incident, I do not accept that it is proven.. After describing Gardner as "the captain of the ship" early in the hearing, he closed the proceedings by using another sailing analogy. That movie is nothing without him! "Taking all the evidence together, I accept that she was the victim of sustained and multiple assaults by Mr. Depp in Australia," the judge said. Depps lawyers argued otherwise. Several big defamation cases are still pending. The actor Johnny Depp wore a bandana as a face mask at the High Court in London on July 7. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); The London judge in Johnny Depps wife-beater case sided with the actors ex, Amber Heard, in nearly all of the male stars alleged violent attacks on her. The $10.35 million award to Mr. Depp was offset by a $2 million partial victory for Ms. Heard, who countersued Mr. Depp for defamation after a lawyer representing him made several statements to a British tabloid calling her abuse accusations a hoax. The jury did not find two of those statements defamatory, but found that a third in which the lawyer had accused Ms. Heard of damaging the couples penthouse and calling 911 to set Mr. Depp up did defame her. pg.acq.push(function() { Another increasingly common issue for Gardner has been dismissing and refiling cases as her understaffed office has struggled to prepare for trials. And the casino mogul Steve Wynn recently agreed to a settlement of a defamation suit he had filed against the lawyer Lisa Bloom, who said she would retract a statement accusing him of inappropriate behavior involving a client. While Britain is sometimes considered hospitable to libel cases, the judge who heard that case, Andrew Nicol, found that there was sufficient proof to conclude that most of the assaults Ms. Heard described had occurred, and he determined that what the newspaper had published was substantially true.. In the wake of the Depp verdict, several lawyers and legal experts said, people accused of assault and misconduct may now be more inclined to try to bring defamation cases to trial. All rights reserved. (AP Photo/Jeff Roberson), EMBATTLED SOROS-BACKED PROSECUTOR, FACING MISSOURI AG EFFORT TO OUST HER, NOW GETS 2024 CHALLENGER. "Justice For Johnny Depp" Petition Reignites Fire For 'Pirates 6 [6] The successful ground for the appeal was that Nicol had failed to instruct the jury properly regarding the grossness element of the offence. It does not appear she has made any reasonable efforts to prevent the resulting chaos.". In an interview with NBCs Today show on Thursday, one of Ms. Heards lawyers, Elaine Charlson Bredehoft, said that the cameras had turned the trial into a zoo.. Andrew George Lindsay Nicol (born 9 May 1951) is a retired judge of the High Court of England and Wales. ga('create', 'UA-67136960-15', 'auto', 'ads'); Judges ruling: [Depp] assaulted Ms. Heard as he had done on previous occasions. Local races came to an end as the St. Lawrence County Board of Elections has released unofficial results for the 2021 General Election on Tuesday night. The prosecutor assigned to the case is on sick leave. Johnny Depp 'did not get fair trial', lawyers tell appeal court }); If you are a British citizen or UK resident, you can sign up here. However, a win for Depp could help him land an injunction against the tabloid. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, Anyone can read what you share. eventAction: 'render' Bullets went through the wall and one struck an 11-year-old girl who was sitting in her bedroom. She hit him with pots and pans 24/7 as if that was okay. Daniel ShenSmith, a practicing barrister in England and Wales, has now launched a change.org petition to allow the 'Pirates of the Caribbean' star to re-appeal a UK judge's 2020 ruling that he assaulted his ex-wife. The petition for rehearing by the panel is also denied. Copyright 2023 IBTimes LLC. He would also get an injunction barring The Sun from repeating the libelous allegations against him, said UK defamation and privacy law expert Daniel Taylor, of Taylor Hampton Solicitors. The judges main ruling came after a three-week trial in which Depp and Heard gave conflicting accounts of their brief, tempestuous marriage. Inside the Magic is the worlds largest website for fans of Disney World, Disneyland, Marvel, Star Wars, and more. While he wasnt named in the piece, he insists it was strongly inferred he was the perpetrator. MEAWW brings you the best content from its global team of PDF draft trial judgment as distributed with corrections - Judiciary Heard claimed that Depp repeatedly beat her in a jealous booze- and drug-fueled rage, severed his fingertip and then scrawled hateful messages to her in his blood. If you are a British citizen or UK resident, you can sign up here. Gardner, who has refused to leave office, has called Bailey's efforts a political witch hunt and a form of "voter suppression," suggesting that racism and sexism are behind some of the criticism against her. "In any event, I do not consider that the proposed grounds of appeal have a reasonable prospect of success (and that is also the case so far as the grounds of appeal suggest that I erred in principle or in law) and there is not some other compelling reason why permission to appeal should be granted.". Thanks for contacting us. Now that this has come to light, Johnny Depp still has not been redeemed of this false news. The bitter legal battle between the actor Johnny Depp and his ex-wife Amber Heard was closely watched in part because it was one of the highest-profile defamation cases to make it to trial recently, and several lawyers said that Mr. Depps victory in a Virginia court on Wednesday when he was awarded more than $10 million in damages could embolden others accused of abuse or misconduct to try their luck with juries, despite the real risks of airing dirty laundry in public. The judge then asked Desilets to appear in court for a hearing on Monday, April 24, with proof of the doctor's appointment and to reschedule the start of trial. Judge Penney S. Azcarate ordered that cameras be allowed, maintaining that Ms. Bredehofts argument about victims of sexual offenses would only pertain to criminal trials. pg.acq.push(function() { However, his fans remain supportive of his legal battle. Depp was ordered to pay about $840,000 to News Group Newspapers, which owns the tabloid, for legal costs. Meanwhile, Noble said Thursday that he will allow Gardner and Desilets to retain attorneys and seek evidence to defend themselves against the contempt charge. All results are listed below and are broken down by the state, county and town levels. Copyright IBTimes 2023. ga('ads.send', { Amber Heard was to be given two million dollars as well, as she was defamed by Depps lawyer Adam Waldman, who called her abuse allegation a hoax.. hitType: 'event', Earlier this month a High Court judge rejected Depp's claim that a newspaper had committed libel when it called him a "wife-beater.". A hearing has been set for May 30. But Mr. Depps victory which a lawyer for Ms. Heard said she would appeal may seem attractive to accused litigants who are desperately seeking a similar redemption arc, said Andrew Miltenberg, a lawyer whose firm regularly defends people accused of sexual misconduct. Right after the Depp-Heard verdict was announced, Mr. Miltenberg said, he received about a dozen emails from clients asking him if it would benefit their cases. He can go directly to the Court of Appeal," another commented after one wrote that Depp wasn't allowed to appeal. PDF IN THE On Petition for Writ of Certiorari Get yours now, The 46 best Mother's Day gift ideas for all moms in 2023, Shop these 7 amazing Amazon deals ahead of this weekend, Best graduation gifts of 2023: 55 ideas for college, high school, more, How to watch 'Citadel': Everything to know about Prime Video's new series, Rihannas iconic Met Gala looks through the years, Sydney Sweeney, fianc Jonathan Davino match in leather amid Glen Powell drama, Celebrities step out in NYC ahead of Met Gala 2023, Elon Musk Tells Bill Maher Woke Mind Virus Is Dangerous On Real Time, 2023 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Johnny Depp spending more time in quiet English countryside, Lily-Rose Depp channels dad Johnnys ex Kate Moss in sheer dress, Devastated Johnny Depp was at Jeff Becks bedside before guitarists death, Lily-Rose Depp defends her silence on Johnny Depp and Amber Heard trial, Nick Cannon celebrates Jada Pinkett Smith's 'Red Table Talk' cancellation: 'Good', Chance the Rapper's wife posts cryptic quote after his dance with another woman, Meghan Trainor 'can't walk' after 'nightmare' sex with 'big boy' Daryl Sabara, Famed New York socialite Patty Raynes found dead in her Palm Beach home, New photo of Meghan Markle that she 'never wanted the world to see', Michael J. Whoopi Goldberg interrupts 'The View' live segment, raises her voice and hits co-host, Baywatch star Jeremy Jacksons ex-wife Loni Willison spotted looking for food in LA waste, 'Liza took a final breath and sighed': Liza Burke, 21, dies 6 weeks after stage 4 cancer diagnosis, 'Go for a size bigger': Honey Boo Boo slammed for flaunting 'tight' prom dress with boyfriend Dralin Carswell. Several high-profile defamation cases in recent years have been settled before they reached trial. } Bailey claims that nearly 12,000 criminal cases have been dismissed to what he calls Gardner's failures. Depp's lawyers argued that their client hadn't received a fair hearing and that Heard was an unreliable witness, considering she hadn't kept her promise to donate her $7 million divorce settlement to charity. "I have found that the great majority of alleged assaults of Ms. Heard by Mr. Depp have been proved to the civil standard," High Court Judge Andrew Nicol said in his judgment, dismissing the. And for what it is worth, I consider that it is unlikely that Ms. Heard or one of her friends was responsible for the feces. eventCategory: event.slot.getSlotElementId(), Have you signed the Justice For Johnny Depp petition? eventAction: 'click_image_ads' [3][4], Nicol was the judge in the trial of consultant surgeon David Sellu in November 2013. A Superior Court judge in Union County was "palpably incorrect" to dismiss a civil case and should have recused himself from the lawsuit that was filed by four Elizabeth police officers who . Also look how fast he responded. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Judge Andrew Nicol ruled last November that Depp had violently assaulted his ex-wife Amber Heard during their tempestuous five-year relationship, at times putting her in fear for her life. hitType: 'event', Gardner is one of the first progressive prosecutors whom Soros, a liberal billionaire and Democrat mega-donor, bankrolled in 2016 and again for her re-election in 2020. The petition titled Re-open Appeal (UK) of Johnny Depp defamation case, following the unanimous US Jury Verdict aims to amass over 75,000 signatures. Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions. Judge shreds Soros-backed prosecutor, moves to hold her in criminal "There is sufficient evidence of disdain and disrespect for the judicial process to determine that both Ms. Gardner and Mr. Desilets' conduct support a finding of indirect criminal contempt. Meanwhile, some believed that it would be best for Depp to just move on from the issue as the legal battle would cost him more. Notifications can be turned off anytime from browser settings. Kim Gardner wants new judge in effort to remove her from office },false) But between the high costs of lawyers fees and the fears of revealing embarrassing details in open court, many such cases are settled before they ever reach trial. wasconcerned, I recognised that the judge in Virginia had made a 'protective order' on 25 th September 2019 which had allowed either party to designate documents as confidential.The protective order had allowed the party concerned to permit documents tobe used for purposes other than the Virginia libel action. As the #MeToo movement fueled a public airing of sexual assault and misconduct allegations, defamation lawsuits quickly became a tool for both the accused and accusers to seek retribution and redemption. Foremost, I am not a Depp movie fan. Depphas been fired from his two most high-profile parts his aforementioned iconic role as Captain Jack Sparrow in Disneys Piratesfranchise and asGellert Grindelwaldin Warner Bros. The assault case over which Gardner may be held in contempt concerns suspect Steven Vincent Jr., who faces nine charges, including first-degree assault, after police say he shot a gun in a St. Louis neighborhood and hit an apartment building. A similar petition was launched on the UK Parliament website by writer PJ Blackmoore. have increasingly turned to defamation suits. Depp recently won against the Aquaman actress in the Fairfax, Virginia court. The jury also awarded Heard compensatory damages of $2 million as she was defamed when Depp's lawyer Adam Waldman called her abuse allegations a hoax. Judges ruling: I conclude that Mr. Depp did assault Ms. Heard.. 3) Allow #Depp to appeal the ruling," Blackmoore wrote on Twitter. Inside the Magic consists of multiple writers & videographers living near both Disneyland and Walt Disney World theme parks and around the world. Once again, the system fails to support and help men of domestic violence. eventCategory: event.slot.getSlotElementId(), [5] After release, Sellu's appeal against the conviction was successful in 2016. Connect with the definitive source for global and local news. Do Not Sell My Personal Information, Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Taylor Swift's Atlanta ticket prices are dropping big time. Appeals should not remotely go back to the Judge. Very clear he read nothing," one added. All Rights Reserved. Related:Johnny Depps Legacy Is Getting Demolished. Quotes displayed in real-time or delayed by at least 15 minutes. Throughout the ongoing jury trial, Depp and his team have been vocal about the fact that the Corpse Bride star had every intention of reprising his role as Captain Jack Sparrow in Disneys Pirates of the Caribbean 6. hitType: 'event', Why WB Firing Amber Heard Would Be Different To Johnny Depp's Exit attorney general files petition to oust Kim Gardner. Sign up and stay up to date with our daily newsletter. Vincent's trial was supposed to begin April 10, but Desilets didn't appear. The proceedings were broadcast and livestreamed far beyond the walls of the courtroom. I am not able to conclude whether there was more than this one assault., Heard said Depp physically attacked her, then sent her text messages saying he was sorry and calling himself a fking savage and lunatic., Judges ruling: I am not persuaded that Incident 6 constituted a physical assault of Ms. Heard by Mr. Depp.. Appeal MUST Be Granted! Following the sensationalized six-week-long trial, the jury made a decision in favor of Johnny Depp with regards to all three counts. let gads_event; document.querySelector("#adunit").addEventListener('click',function(){ Andrew S Moses. Nicol delivered his verdict on Depp's case in November 2020. Sitemap, Your California Privacy Rights (function(e,t,n,r){var i=n.currentScript,s=null;if(i)s=i;else{var o=n.getElementsByTagName(r),u=o.length-1;for(var a=u;a>=0;a--)if(o[a].getAttribute("rel")==="skimlinks-ref-banner"){s=o[a];break}}s&&setTimeout(function(){var i=e[t]||(e[t]=[]),o={"imageUrl":"/banners/img/referral/higher_commissions/728X90.gif","wid":"07","creativeId":60710,"color":"grey","size":"728X90","domainId":"1601785","publisherId":137930,"bannerUrl":"/banners/js/referral/referral_banner.min.js","cdnUrl":"https://s.skimresources.com"};if(i.length===0){var u=n.createElement(r);u.src=o.cdnUrl+o.bannerUrl,u.async=!0,s.parentNode.insertBefore(u,s)}i.push({el:s,config:o})})})(this,"__skimlinksBanners",document,"script"); CONTACT US | ADVERTISE ON ITM However, Judge Andrew Nicol issued a damning verdict against the actor. Sir Andrew (George Lindsay), Who's Who 2014, A & C Black, an imprint of Bloomsbury Publishing plc, 2014, judge of the High Court of England and Wales, "Middle Temple Masters of the Bench - The Hon Mr Justice Andrew Nicol", "Secret justice will lead to paranoia and it's not very British", "Poor, bad and truly atrocious: Directing the jury on gross negligence manslaughter", "Actor Depp loses bid to appeal wife beater libel ruling, turns to U.S. case", "Why did the Depp-Heard libel outcomes differ in the US and UK? Depp can still apply directly to the Court of Appeal, and has until Dec. 7 to do so. While Britain is sometimes considered hospitable to libel cases, the judge who heard that case, Andrew Nicol, found that there was sufficient proof to conclude that most of the assaults Ms.. eventAction: 'load' Their prime witness is the 34-year-old Justice League actress, who testified that her ex-husband had beaten her more than a dozen times during their relationship. Depp is also suing Heard for $50 million in Virginia over a Washington Post op-ed essay that she wrote about domestic violence. SLC District Attorney. Gullible?Or is there something more cynical here? Several lawyers noted that Mr. Depp and Ms. Heards battle was so complex and singular in its level of public spectacle that people should be wary of drawing any lasting conclusions about how their own legal proceedings would unfold. 3) Allow #Depp to appeal the ruling," Blackmoore wrote on Twitter. Those who assist the prosecution can and should be protected by other means. However, taken with the evidence as a whole, I find that it did occur.. }); ", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Andrew_Nicol_(judge)&oldid=1150508477, This page was last edited on 18 April 2023, at 15:50. The Edward Scissorhands actor stands to lose a lot more if the judge rules in The Suns favor than he would gain if he won. }); Demi Moore has not left Bruce Willis's side and is doing everything to make his 'last moments happy', 'Stop it!' Petition Officially Review the Judicial misconduct of JUDGE NICOL in Judge Nicole obviously denied it and they knew he would. According to an investigation by local CBS affiliate KMOV, the reason for the dismissal and refiling is that "the prosecutors weren't ready for trial," which had been set to take place in a matter of days. Judge Michael Noble announced he will appoint a special prosecutor to oversee the contempt case against St. Louis Circuit Attorney Kimberly Gardner, the city's top prosecutor, and Assistant Circuit Attorney Chris Desilets after no one from Gardner's office appeared at a trial and subsequent hearing in an assault case involving the wounding of an 11-year-old girl. At this time, as noted, the former couple isappearing in courtin relation to their$50 million U.S. civil lawsuit. Here are the 14 incidents that High Court Judge Andrew Nicol specifically listed in his opinion released Monday siding with Heard along with his take on each: "Incident 1: the tattoo incident" It almost beggars belief that anyone rational has taken this case to court, said Mark Stephens, a media lawyer at legal firm Howard Kennedy. window.googletag.pubads().addEventListener('slotRenderEnded', function(event) { If The Sun wins the case, then Johnny Depp has to pay all their costs, and if Johnny Depp wins the case, The Sun has to pay his costs, he told The Post. While British libel law is widely considered to favor claimants, like Depp, over defendants, the Hollywood superstar probably wont win big, experts said. A Change.org petition to allow Johnny Depp to re-appeal his UK libel lawsuit against The Sun has appeared online. Change.org Uh oh. Johnny Depp unable to appeal 'wife beater' ruling, judge says - Yahoo We focus on bringing you all things fun so you can plan your theme park vacation, enjoy Disney at home, and more. But in a setback for the Pirates of the Caribbean star, Nicol denied permission to appeal, saying I do not consider that the proposed grounds of appeal have a reasonable prospect of success.. Whichever side wins, the verdict can be appealed all the way to the UK Supreme Court which also means the legal costs could just be starting, the experts said. Kevin J Crosby (Vote for BOTH of our GOP Coroners) June H Wood (Vote for BOTH of our GOP Coroners) Town of BRASHER. "Correction: Johnny Depp can apply. Here are the 14 incidents that High Court Judge Andrew Nicol specifically listed in his opinion released Monday siding with Heard along with his take on each: Heard alleged that Depp hit her for the first time in early 2013 because she laughed at him over his Wino Forever tattoo as he boozed it up on whiskey and wine. Johnny Depp is a wife beater, UK judge rules in libel case window.googletag.pubads().addEventListener('impressionViewable', function(event) { However, there are no court records of her office, which is responsible for monitoring compliance with bond conditions and revoking them when those terms are violated, asking for Riley's bond to be revoked, according to local reports. Petition for re-appeal in Johnny Depp's UK libel case against The Sun amasses over 53K signatures. No judge likes to see their decisions appealed, especially with such a high-profile case, Dunleavy added. Regardless, we CANNOT remain silent here.Depps suit against The Sun newspaper MUST be heard again in a UK court. I imagine part of the reason theyll feel emboldened is beyond the verdict itself but the public reaction to it., The trial was captured by two cameras in the courtroom that allowed the testimony to be packaged into memes and online commentary much of which mocked Ms. Heards accusations of abuse. Both prosecutors could face jail time or a fine if found guilty. For years, Gardner's office has faced criticism for mishandling cases and office dysfunction. . Disney Guest Disappointed In Beloved Food Item, It Couldve Broken Teeth, Guest Claims Disney Bus Stank and Drivers Were Incredibly Rude, Inside the Magic Your Ultimate Source for Themed EntertainmentCoverage, reprising his role as Captain Jack Sparrow, Johnny Depps Legacy Is Getting Demolished, that there was a $22.5 million deal on the table, Johnny Depp Becomes Real-Life Jack Sparrow, Owns Pirates of the Caribbean Island, Depp and a close friend referred to Heards rotting corpse, allegedly exposed Heards multiple mental disorders, continued and vehement denial of the domestic abuse claims against him, long-lived Justice For Johnny Depp petition, Johnny Depps Pirates Considered Doomed to Fail, Judge Denies Amber Heards Motion to Throw Out Depp Case, Trial to Continue, Margot Robbie is expected to take over the leading role, Divisive Amber Heard Blamed For Aquaman Star Jason Momoas Divorce. document.querySelector("#google_image_div").addEventListener('click',function(){ In. Judges ruling: There is evidence which I find compelling of witnesses who saw Ms. Heard with injuries to her face and who took photographs of these. February 07, 2023 Order Entered at the Direction of the Court: Clerk, U.S. Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit. Fox says Parkinson's battle getting 'harder': 'I'm not gonna be 80', Kim Kardashian seemingly shades Kourtney's wedding in now-deleted caption amid feud, Prince Harry snubbed from coronation as William's role is revealed, Kendall Jenner rocks sheer top, fur mini skirt for date night with Bad Bunny, Padma Lakshmi claps back at trolls: 'I have boobs, I have nipples', Woman has 'loud and full body orgasm' during LA Philharmonic concert. "It appears that Ms. Gardner has complete indifference and a conscious disregard for the judicial process," Noble said during a hearing to address the no-shows. At some level, mud sticks.. The Pirates of the Caribbean star had sued her for $50 million. The petition for rehearing en banc is denied. Johnny Depps Win in Court Could Embolden Others, Lawyers Say, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/02/arts/depp-metoo-defamation.html. Two Court of Appeal judges, namely James Dingemans and Nicholas Underhill, said the 'Donnie Brasco' star couldn't challenge the High Courts rejection of his libel lawsuit against NGN, the publisher of The Sun newspaper, for branding him as a wife-beater in an article. Johnny Depp Loses 'Wife-Beater' Libel Case Against the Sun - Insider 18,308, This story has been shared 17,884 times. This may come as a joke to some, but abuse towards a man or woman is not to be taken lightly. US star Johnny Depp had sued the Sun over claims he was violent to ex-wife Amber Heard during their volatile two-year marriage, Stay up to date with our daily newsletter, Johnny Depp Poses From Behind Bars To Accept Award Weeks After Losing Libel Case, Mads Mikkelsen Addresses Rumors He's Replacing Johnny Depp In 'Fantastic Beasts 3', US Markets Mixed After First Republic Bank Takeover, Autopsies In Kenya Cult Deaths Confirm Starvation, Macron Minister Raises Eyebrows With Racy Novel, Canadian Federal Workers Get May Day Deal To End Strike, Scientists Use Brain Scans And AI To 'Decode' Thoughts, Johnny Depp's appeal for his "wife-beater" libel case was denied by Judge Andrew Nicol, Depp's fans urged him to take his appeal to the High Court, Twitter users remain supportive of Depp's legal battle despite the appeals rejection. ShenSmith calls himself the Blackbelt Barrister on social media. The Pirates leading man was let go by The Walt Disney Company following a 2018 Washington Post op-ed in which Heard claimed she suffered domestic abuse at Depps hands.

My Mother Gave Me My First Cigarette, Richest Person In Vietnam 2021, What Does The Name Antoinette Mean In The Bible, Articles J

judge andrew nicol petition